CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jeffrey collins
    Not cool enough
    • Jun 2004
    • 7427

    Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

    where did you hear this???? i want facts to back this up.
    Jeffrey Collins: Painter
    My Painting Blog

    http://soundcloud.com/jeffreycollins
    My Soundcloud page.

    Comment

    • kassios
      Platinum Poster
      • Jun 2004
      • 1200

      Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

      Yeah this is deep!!!!

      As long as there's roaches vinyl will still be around
      http://soundcloud.com/concept-sheep

      Comment

      • jeffrey collins
        Not cool enough
        • Jun 2004
        • 7427

        Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

        ^^^ yepper.
        Jeffrey Collins: Painter
        My Painting Blog

        http://soundcloud.com/jeffreycollins
        My Soundcloud page.

        Comment

        • victorgonzales
          Getting warmed up
          • Nov 2006
          • 51

          Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

          Originally posted by jeffrey collins
          where did you hear this???? i want facts to back this up.
          If your refering to my post. I know this because a guy I know cutts vinyl and he says he has do do certain mastering things to make certain frequencies transfer to vinyl well. Hes been audio engineering to vinyl for ten years so I believe him. He told me all the tracks always sound warmer in the midrange once put onto vinyl and the highs loose the cripness they had before the transfer.

          Not saying it is a bad thing but it is just what happens.

          Comment

          • Yao
            DUDERZ get a life!!!
            • Jun 2004
            • 8167

            Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

            I think Gonzales is right: the quality cannot get better when transferred, that is impossible. What IS possible however is that the vinyl ads the warm and full flavour to the sound which so many people love. Not better in the absolute sense then, but different in a positive way

            I love vinyl but with that stuff being so incredibly expensive at the moment, I'm gonna re-enter dj-ing with CDJ's and digital music. Too bad, but probably the best choice for me.
            Blowkick visual & graphic design - No Civilization. Now With Broadband.

            There are but three true sports -- bullfighting, mountain climbing, and motor-racing. The rest are merely games. -Hemingway

            Comment

            • jeffrey collins
              Not cool enough
              • Jun 2004
              • 7427

              Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

              I have been listening to some older vinyl stuff, and a lot of it...personally...i think has to do with the way it was recorded, mixed, and mastered. A lot of tracks just flat out stink with the way they were recorded. I was listening to some Jimi yesterday and hearing it i'd love to strangle Chas Chandler and Eddie Kramer for fucking up what could have been an awesome recording.
              Jeffrey Collins: Painter
              My Painting Blog

              http://soundcloud.com/jeffreycollins
              My Soundcloud page.

              Comment

              • BureOne
                Are you Kidding me??
                • Jun 2004
                • 3285

                Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                Last night as I was packing some of the last vinyl's off my shelf I came across a Bedrock record. Evol D - Insect OMFG!!! what a fucking track!!!!

                Comment

                • ganjamo
                  Platinum Poster
                  • Jan 2006
                  • 1373

                  Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                  Id love to use vinyl but getting em in my country is almost impossible since there are only 1 or 2 shops and they dont have the good stuff.
                  CDs are just more practical, dowload, burn and play. smaller also.
                  technology advances, and its for good
                  Dont panic, its organic.

                  Comment

                  • kalin
                    Getting warmed up
                    • Jun 2005
                    • 58

                    Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                    Originally posted by victorgonzales
                    If your refering to my post. I know this because a guy I know cutts vinyl and he says he has do do certain mastering things to make certain frequencies transfer to vinyl well. Hes been audio engineering to vinyl for ten years so I believe him. He told me all the tracks always sound warmer in the midrange once put onto vinyl and the highs loose the cripness they had before the transfer.

                    Not saying it is a bad thing but it is just what happens.
                    You're on the right track here. Whenever a tracks is to get released, the master copy the artist provides is mastered for the media it is going to get released on (either digital or vinyl). it is true that high-end is not that crisp, but that's a limitation of the vinyl pressing and playback process, it can go up to just 18KHz, so mastering engineers account for that during the creation of the vinyl master. However, sometimes that "crispness" you're referring to may be just overblown high-end due to poorer home-studio equipment, etc.

                    To me it's just a question of personal taste whether you like your sound sharper and crisper, but lacking somewhat in the mids and the bottom end (that "metallic"-sounding bass, I'm not a native speaker, so I'm using a term from my background) or you prefer solid, punchy low-end and warmer mids and highs. It's not a loss of quality, it's just a different kind of quality and it ultimately comes down to personal choice.
                    It comes from inside, just listen ...

                    Comment

                    • billyz
                      Addiction started
                      • Dec 2006
                      • 325

                      Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                      You guys rock! I never realized I would get such a response from this post and such diversity in knowledge. It is refreshing to see such passion for collecting or playing which ever your case maybe and I look forward to hearing more from whomever may post in the thread. Thank you all and keep posting. Billy Z
                      Billy Z
                      soundcloud.com/djbillyz
                      mixcloud.com/djbillyz
                      twitter.com/djbillyz
                      twitter.com/bluePRINTSaturo
                      instagram.com/djbillyz
                      djbillyz.com

                      Comment

                      • jeffrey collins
                        Not cool enough
                        • Jun 2004
                        • 7427

                        Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                        if only there were more people in this world that cared as much about music as we do.
                        Jeffrey Collins: Painter
                        My Painting Blog

                        http://soundcloud.com/jeffreycollins
                        My Soundcloud page.

                        Comment

                        • Yao
                          DUDERZ get a life!!!
                          • Jun 2004
                          • 8167

                          Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                          Hey, but that would makes us less special man
                          Blowkick visual & graphic design - No Civilization. Now With Broadband.

                          There are but three true sports -- bullfighting, mountain climbing, and motor-racing. The rest are merely games. -Hemingway

                          Comment

                          • jeffrey collins
                            Not cool enough
                            • Jun 2004
                            • 7427

                            Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                            nah, we are still special. So it would make us extra special.
                            Jeffrey Collins: Painter
                            My Painting Blog

                            http://soundcloud.com/jeffreycollins
                            My Soundcloud page.

                            Comment

                            • kassios
                              Platinum Poster
                              • Jun 2004
                              • 1200

                              Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                              Im so happy i found this place for music!!
                              Teens say they like vinyl records over CDs
                              http://soundcloud.com/concept-sheep

                              Comment

                              • victorgonzales
                                Getting warmed up
                                • Nov 2006
                                • 51

                                Re: CD's vs Vinyl and Why!

                                one thing I will definately give vinyl an edge with is ease of playing. I prefer the crips sound of digital and producers are starting to improve their digital tracks to add warmth and whatnot that got left behind when they stopped putting tracks on vinyl.

                                But..... Cdjs just arent as fun to play on as vinyl. I love how easy it is to speed up or fix problems with a slight touch on a record. No cdj has been able to replicate the feel of the techs so far.

                                Im goin cdj all the way now cuz I love playing my own tracks and stuff that NOONE else has but I cant wait for the technology to catch up and make playing cds more comfortable.

                                Comment

                                Working...