Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mnbvcxz
    Platinum Poster
    • Feb 2006
    • 1312

    #16
    Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

    Oh no, look out... another list!

    Comment

    • josalo
      Addiction started
      • Apr 2008
      • 347

      #17
      Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

      Trance Djs comments are realy sutpid


      Paul Van Dyk
      GARETH EMERY comment:
      "In 2002, I sent Paul van Dyk a CD of my first track, unmastered. Next thing, someone rang up and said van Dyk played it live on radio at Nature One, a big festival in Germany. That track was 'Mistral'....
      Resume, Paul Van Dyk s greatest because he played your track....Are your fucking me?

      Tiesto
      SANDER VAN DOORN comment:
      ...From the moment I started producing, he picked my music up and promoted it – he's one of the DJs who got me where I am today. He sells out stadiums, but never comes across as big-headed or arrogant...
      Poor Sander Van Doorn....
      "superdeepsexyhypergroovalicioustrpfunkhousevi bes"

      Comment

      • Michael^Heaven
        Platinum Poster
        • May 2008
        • 1321

        #18
        Re:

        That list is too convoluted with overlapping genres. Perhaps, if it was seperated into categories, accurate choice(s) could be achieved.

        That being said,

        Comment

        • Shpira
          Angry Boy Child
          • Oct 2006
          • 4969

          #19
          Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

          how do you define "greatest"?
          The Idiots ARE Winning.


          "Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect."
          Mark Twain

          SOBRIETY MIX

          Comment

          • bobjuice
            Banned
            • May 2008
            • 4894

            #20
            Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

            Originally posted by Shpira
            how do you define "greatest"?
            By accepting that we're all different in every way we are influenced, the period of time we came of age, our particular personality in relation to music and a million other factors that make anything as subjective as artistic performance something you can't compare between one another, never mind different time periods so just enjoy what you enjoy and stop making the whole world a fuckin pop chart. Is Larry Levan the greatest? Tiesto may think not. But they are simply people who put records on in clubs for fuck's sake. One may have influenced everything you've ever done or you may have just gone out clubbing for a certain period of your life and enjoyed everything that came with it and that's all, so fucking what?

            My favourite colour is green but i'd be interested to know about other peoples' favourite socks

            Comment

            • bobjuice
              Banned
              • May 2008
              • 4894

              #21
              Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

              Let's see what the greatest DJ of them all has to say on the matter?




              Comment

              • Shpira
                Angry Boy Child
                • Oct 2006
                • 4969

                #22
                Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                Originally posted by bobjuice
                By accepting that we're all different in every way we are influenced, the period of time we came of age, our particular personality in relation to music and a million other factors that make anything as subjective as artistic performance something you can't compare between one another, never mind different time periods so just enjoy what you enjoy and stop making the whole world a fuckin pop chart. Is Larry Levan the greatest? Tiesto may think not. But they are simply people who put records on in clubs for fuck's sake. One may have influenced everything you've ever done or you may have just gone out clubbing for a certain period of your life and enjoyed everything that came with it and that's all, so fucking what?

                My favourite colour is green but i'd be interested to know about other peoples' favourite socks

                I think that was my point...but hey your rant works as well
                The Idiots ARE Winning.


                "Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect."
                Mark Twain

                SOBRIETY MIX

                Comment

                • bobjuice
                  Banned
                  • May 2008
                  • 4894

                  #23
                  Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                  Comment

                  • 88Mariner
                    My dick is smaller
                    • Nov 2006
                    • 7128

                    #24
                    Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                    Originally posted by Shpira
                    how do you define "greatest"?
                    i think it's a more objective take on the dj's career. i would have otherwise voted oakenfold since he basically pulled me back into electronic music. but given that his productions have been rather poor and his inability to mix has become more observed over the last decade, it's hard for me to say he's goat. i think the goat needs to have consistency in rocking the venues they play (i.e. not having off nights), the ability to play a wide selection of tunes (instead of, say, only the records on your own label or your own mixes back to back to back), a stream of singles and mix compilations (if you're putting out a compilation every few years, then wtf right?), and have had a strong part in the polularization of edm in general. (and, I'd say, been around at the top of your game for at least two of the last three decades as well - greatest of all time, if you think about it, means you've also been in the scene a long time. not a johnny-come-lately dj. at least that's how i look at it).

                    i think you could find maybe 10 -15 dj's who fit that profile that nobody can really argue about. (some of which, ahem, aren't on that list). i think from there you can start making subjective points.

                    whatev tho, as someone said above, 'oh look another list!
                    you could put an Emfire release on for 2 minutes and you would be a sleep before it finishes - Chunky

                    it's RA. they'd blow their load all over some stupid 20 minute loop of a snare if it had a quirky flange setting. - Tiddles

                    Am I somewhere....in the corners of your mind....

                    ----PEACE-----

                    Comment

                    • Shpira
                      Angry Boy Child
                      • Oct 2006
                      • 4969

                      #25
                      Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                      but given that his productions have been rather poor
                      I think that this definitely has nothing to do with the poll.
                      i think the goat needs to have consistency in rocking the venues they play (i.e. not having off nights), the ability to play a wide selection of tunes (instead of, say, only the records on your own label or your own mixes back to back to back), a stream of singles and mix compilations (if you're putting out a compilation every few years, then wtf right?), and have had a strong part in the polularization of edm in general. (and, I'd say, been around at the top of your game for at least two of the last three decades as well - greatest of all time, if you think about it, means you've also been in the scene a long time. not a johnny-come-lately dj. at least that's how i look at it).
                      The Idiots ARE Winning.


                      "Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect."
                      Mark Twain

                      SOBRIETY MIX

                      Comment

                      • thebanned1
                        DUDERZ get a life!!!
                        • May 2009
                        • 5032

                        #26
                        Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                        Originally posted by bobjuice
                        Let's see what the greatest DJ of them all has to say on the matter?




                        good point!!! its shocking that he's not even in it
                        How to Check the True Bitrate of Your Audio Files - Make Tech Easier

                        Comment

                        • bobjuice
                          Banned
                          • May 2008
                          • 4894

                          #27
                          Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                          Comment

                          • bobjuice
                            Banned
                            • May 2008
                            • 4894

                            #28
                            Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                            Originally posted by thebanned1
                            its shocking that he's not even in it
                            shoddy indeed eh?

                            Comment

                            • DIDI
                              Aussie Pest
                              • Nov 2004
                              • 16845

                              #29
                              Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                              Originally posted by Shpira
                              I think that this definitely has nothing to do with the poll.


                              Why do I have a sudden urge to claw my eyes out ???
                              Originally posted by TheVrk
                              it IS incredible isn't it??
                              STILL pumpin out great set after great set...never cheesed out, never sold out, never lost his touch..
                              Simply does not get any better than Hernan
                              The 'club spirit' is in the soul. It Never Dies

                              Comment

                              • Huggie Smiles
                                Anyone have Styx livesets?
                                • Jun 2004
                                • 11837

                                #30
                                Re: Who is the greatest DJ of all time?

                                Originally posted by bobjuice
                                Let's see what the greatest DJ of them all has to say on the matter?

                                whilst I know that Bob loves the jimmy *cough* ; Peel > Saville any day of the week, and twice on Fridays.
                                ....Freak in the morning, Freak in the evening, aint no other Freak like me thats breathing....




                                Comment

                                Working...